Petition for Intentional Technology Use in Vista Schools
A campaign from Schools Beyond Screens - Schools Beyond Screens - Vista
Sign This Campaign
155
Signatures
155 of 300 signatures
52% to goal
Every action matters
Recent supporters:
Parent signed
about 17 hours ago
Parent signed
6 days ago
Grandparent signed
6 days ago
Why This Matters
We are asking the Vista Unified School District to adopt healthier, safer, and more balanced technology policies that protect childhood, support real learning, and prioritize students over screens.
Created by Schools Beyond Screens - Vista
Learn more: https://www.schoolsbeyondscreens.com/c/vista
Dear Superintendent Doyle and Vista Unified Board Members,
We are writing to urge the Vista Unified School District (VUSD) to take bold action on the growing crisis of excessive screen time in our schools.
We are a coalition of parents, educators, and community members in Vista concerned about the over-reliance on screen-based learning in our classrooms. We recognize the value of technology in education, but we are asking VUSD to adopt a more intentional, evidence-based approach to how and when devices are used.
Despite significant investments in 1:1 devices and educational technology (EdTech), research consistently demonstrates that excessive screen time fragments attention, impairs deep thinking, and negatively impacts student mental health. Comprehension and retention are proven to be stronger when students read physical books, write on paper, and learn directly from their teachers. Furthermore, the use of internet-connected devices in the classroom frequently shifts our teachers from educators to monitors of online behavior.
Districts across the country are responding to this evidence by implementing thoughtful guardrails. We respectfully ask VUSD to commit to an Intentional Technology Plan for the 2027-2028 school year and beyond.
Our Requests
We are writing to urge the Vista Unified School District (VUSD) to take bold action on the growing crisis of excessive screen time in our schools.
We are a coalition of parents, educators, and community members in Vista concerned about the over-reliance on screen-based learning in our classrooms. We recognize the value of technology in education, but we are asking VUSD to adopt a more intentional, evidence-based approach to how and when devices are used.
Despite significant investments in 1:1 devices and educational technology (EdTech), research consistently demonstrates that excessive screen time fragments attention, impairs deep thinking, and negatively impacts student mental health. Comprehension and retention are proven to be stronger when students read physical books, write on paper, and learn directly from their teachers. Furthermore, the use of internet-connected devices in the classroom frequently shifts our teachers from educators to monitors of online behavior.
Districts across the country are responding to this evidence by implementing thoughtful guardrails. We respectfully ask VUSD to commit to an Intentional Technology Plan for the 2027-2028 school year and beyond.
Our Requests
We urge the Vista Unified School District to adopt a comprehensive screen time policy that includes the following:
Establish Age-Appropriate Device Limits
Establish Age-Appropriate Device Limits
- TK–2nd Grade: Eliminate the use of 1:1 district-issued Chromebooks and iPads, except where required for mandated state assessments. Early education must prioritize hands-on, multi-sensory, and interpersonal learning.
- 3rd–8th Grade: Transition from a 1:1 model to shared classroom device carts or computer labs, reserving technology for tasks where it offers a clear, evidence-backed advantage over traditional methods.
Prioritize and Fund Analog Learning
- Establish a district-wide culture that defaults to physical books, printed materials, and paper-based assignments, ensuring homework can be completed offline to protect home life and sleep.
- Reallocate funding from ineffective digital tools toward physical learning materials, textbooks, and updated analog resources.
- Provide educators with dedicated professional development, paid planning time, and the necessary physical manipulatives to fully support them in a less screen-dependent classroom.
Protect Unstructured Time
- Prohibit the recreational use of school-issued devices during free time, passing periods, lunch, and recess. Unstructured time is critical for social-emotional development and mental rest, and should not be replaced by screen time.
- Digital device use must not be utilized as a behavioral reward or classroom incentive.
Prioritize Technology Education Over Education Technology
- Recognize the critical difference between teaching computer skills and delivering general education via screens.
- Implement a formal digital literacy curriculum (teaching typing, research skills, and the ethical implications of tech) led by trained instructors, rather than using devices as the primary delivery method for core subjects like reading and math.
Enforce Digital Safety and Content Guardrails
- Block student-directed access to non-educational platforms, including YouTube, social media, and unregulated AI/chatbot tools, on all district networks and devices.
- Restrict access to highly gamified learning apps that prioritize engagement metrics and short-term rewards over deep learning.
- Require that all applications used on school-issued devices be completely free of advertising, and prohibit apps that push paid upgrades, in-app purchases, or freemium features to students and families.
Implement a Moratorium on Student-Facing Generative AI
- Institute a pause on the procurement, licensing, and approved student use of Generative AI products, including Large Language Models (LLMs), AI chatbots, and AI content generators.
- Disable Generative AI features on all currently approved software. If features cannot be disabled, phase the product out of student use.
- Allow exceptions strictly for legally-mandated accommodations (e.g., IEPs, 504 plans, medical needs) or when formally approved by a district administrator as strictly necessary to achieve a specific curriculum objective that cannot be met otherwise.
Ensure Accountability, Oversight, and Financial Transparency
- Require that any new technology, app, or software be independently proven to improve educational outcomes before classroom introduction, rather than relying on vendor-funded research.
- Publish a detailed public audit of all funds spent on educational technology over the past five school years, including hardware, software licensing, and infrastructure.
- Form an Expert Educational Technology Committee comprised of educators, caregivers, and child development experts who are free of financial conflicts of interest with EdTech companies to review research and district policies annually.
Ensure Transparency and Meaningful Parental Consent
- Move away from blanket technology consent forms. Require explicit, individual parental consent for every application that collects student data, in compliance with COPPA guidelines.
- Provide parents with automated, weekly reports detailing their child’s screen activity on district-issued devices.
- Clearly define and communicate opt-out pathways for families who prefer low-tech learning alternatives for their children without academic penalty.
The VUSD community has seen firsthand how screens impact our children's ability to focus, connect with their peers, and engage in meaningful learning. Our goal is not to banish technology from Vista schools, but to shift the paradigm. Technology should be a tool used to enhance education, not the primary method of delivery that pushes our highly-qualified teachers to the sidelines.
We respectfully urge Vista Unified to act swiftly and intentionally to protect the health, development, and academic success of our children.
The time to act is now.
Sincerely,
The undersigned
We respectfully urge Vista Unified to act swiftly and intentionally to protect the health, development, and academic success of our children.
The time to act is now.
Sincerely,
The undersigned
Recent Supporters
-
about 17 hours ago
Parent
Signed in Vista, CA
-
6 days ago
Parent
Signed in Vista, CA
-
6 days ago
Grandparent
Signed in Vista, CA
155 supporters have signed this campaign
Sign This Campaign
155
Signatures
155 of 300 signatures
52% to goal
Every action matters
Recent supporters:
Parent signed
about 17 hours ago
Parent signed
6 days ago
Grandparent signed
6 days ago
Share This Campaign
Need to share on your social networks or via text? Copy this link and paste it into your message.